By Brett Ungashick, Founder of Outsail
In the early days of building an HR process and team, leaders lean heavily on their core HRIS. It’s the system of record, the workflow engine, and often the de facto compliance tool. But as teams grow, especially across state lines, cracks begin to form in that HRIS compliance structure.
Simply put, the traditional HRIS wasn’t built to manage the full weight of multi-state compliance. And for teams moving off of PEOs, the complexity becomes even more pronounced. That’s why evaluating your HRIS early, and understanding where it supports compliance versus where it falls short, is critical to scaling smoothly.
Today’s workforce is increasingly distributed. Employees relocate more freely, hybrid and remote work are standard, and companies are scaling faster than ever. That flexibility is good for talent acquisition and retention, but it brings real challenges for compliance, taxes, labor law adherence, and risk mitigation.
Key Takeaways
- Traditional HRIS systems aren’t designed to handle the complexity of multi-state compliance requirements alone
- A “compliance stack” approach fills critical gaps left by standalone HRIS platforms through integrated tools and services
- Companies exiting PEOs face the biggest compliance risks without proper system architecture to replace bundled services
- The future of HR lies in building modular, AI-enhanced systems that scale with distributed teams and automate low-value compliance tasks
Why Traditional HRIS Falls Short for Multi-State Compliance
Most HR teams eventually realize that compliance isn’t just a box to check during onboarding. It’s an ongoing, dynamic process. Each state, and sometimes locality, has its own regulations around employment, payroll, taxes, benefits, and recordkeeping. Missing a registration, underestimating tax obligations, or failing to deliver a required notice can result in fines, or worse, a degraded employee experience that affects trust and morale.
That’s where the concept of a “compliance stack” becomes essential.
While your HRIS might offer some built-in features like E-Verify, document management, or standard templates, it’s rarely sufficient on its own for high compliance environments. The compliance stack is the set of tools, workflows, and external services that fill the gaps left by your HRIS. Think of it as the scaffolding that ensures your tech stack is ready to scale responsibly.
The Hidden Compliance Gaps When Exiting PEOs
Exiting a PEO is often the moment when companies realize this compliance shortcoming. PEOs bundle HRIS, payroll, benefits, and compliance into a single platform, but when companies leave a PEO, they have to recreate that bundle themselves. That means finding a new HRIS, a payroll vendor, and often a compliance solution to make sure they’re meeting multi-state registration and tax requirements.
It’s in these moments that gaps are most likely to show up. Teams assume payroll will handle taxes automatically, but there are often responsibilities that the company still has. Or they expect their HRIS to alert them to compliance changes, but that’s rarely the case. Many HR teams end up building spreadsheets or using manual trackers to stay compliant, which is neither scalable nor accurate.
Building Your Compliance Stack: Essential Components
So, where does an HR team begin rebuilding after a PEO exit? A well-built compliance stack typically includes these key elements:
- Core HRIS and payroll engine that integrates tightly with benefits and time tracking
- Workflow tools for document collection, policy sign off, and I-9 verification
- Registered agent or compliance support services for multi-state registration and ongoing filings
- Automated alerts and checklists for onboarding in new jurisdictions
- Audit friendly systems that log changes, flag anomalies, and ensure data integrity
Of course, the goal isn’t to needlessly complicate compliance by layering on more solutions. Instead, companies need to find the right partners for their specific needs. For example, a platform like Mosey can handle the complex registrations, filings, and state-by-state obligations that most HRIS platforms can’t manage natively, offering the type of specialized compliance partnership that helps teams scale confidently.
Ready to transition off your PEO?
Download the complete guide of everything you need to know for a successful transition. Tools, strategies, and timeline included!
The Role of AI in Modern Compliance Automation Software
Zooming in further, as AI becomes more embedded in modern HR software systems, there’s also a growing opportunity to automate low value compliance tasks. That could include:
- Ensuring employee handbooks stay current without manual updates
- Surfacing required state notices during the onboarding process
- Flagging anomalies in pay equity or contractor classification
- Recommending updates based on changes to federal and state labor laws
The point isn’t to replace HR professionals with AI but to give HR teams more capacity to think strategically, rather than spend cycles chasing paperwork or searching for state law updates.
How to Evaluate Your HRIS Software and Compliance Requirements
The key to building a resilient HRIS and compliance stack is starting with the right evaluation process. That means taking these critical steps:
- Auditing what your current software handles, and where it falls short
- Mapping out your current and future footprint
- Asking vendors for real, in context demos, not just feature overviews
- Confirming how systems handle changes like an employee moving to a new state
- Looking at long term costs beyond the sticker price: What will you spend in time, expertise, and risk exposure?
Many of the tools that support this process aren’t flashy. They could be software platforms, but they might also be service layers, offering compliance playbooks, filing support, and ongoing monitoring for new legal requirements.
The bottom line is this: even best in class HRIS solutions likely still need a strong partner to round out the compliance side. Likewise, great compliance services won’t replace a robust management system of record or efficient workflow automation. Therefore, building a bulletproof system means looking holistically and filling gaps strategically.
The best setups are modular. They grow with you. Whether you’re managing 10 employees in two states or 500 employees in 35, your software should offer the same confidence, clarity, and audit readiness, no matter the circumstances or needs. When things go wrong, because sometimes they do, your systems and support should help you respond quickly, not leave you scrambling. That assumes, of course, that you choose the right partners and solutions in the first place.
The Future of HR Management System Architecture
In a world where teams move fast and employees move often, compliance cannot be an afterthought. It’s infrastructure. Foundational. A robust compliance stack allows HR professionals to scale confidently, knowing the base is solid.
As organizations continue to shift systems, the forward-looking ones know that the transition doesn’t end with selecting a payroll vendor. Instead, a capable compliance stack unlocks flexibility, ensures alignment with every jurisdiction, and allows your team to focus on people, not paperwork.
The next generation of HR professionals won’t just be culture champions. They’ll be system architects. And the ones who build the right foundation now will lead with confidence and clarity tomorrow.
Frequently Asked Questions: HRIS + Multi-State Compliance
Still have questions about managing HRIS compliance across multiple states? Here are answers to help you build effective compliance systems for your organization.
What is HRIS compliance?
HRIS compliance means ensuring your Human Resource Information System follows all legal and regulatory requirements for handling employee data and HR processes. This includes meeting federal laws, state regulations, and data privacy rules that apply to your business locations.
What is a compliance stack for HRIS?
A compliance stack for HRIS is a set of tools and services that work with your main HR system to handle complex compliance needs. Your HRIS covers basic functions, but the compliance stack adds specialized features like multi-state tracking and automated regulatory updates.
How do you handle HRIS compliance across multiple states?
Handling HRIS compliance across multiple states requires mapping each state’s specific rules and using systems that can track these differences automatically. Most companies use specialized compliance tools alongside their HRIS and follow the strictest state requirements to stay compliant everywhere.
What compliance gaps exist when leaving a PEO?
When leaving a PEO, companies must handle compliance tasks that the PEO previously managed automatically, including state registrations and tax filings. Many businesses underestimate these responsibilities and struggle with manual tracking or missed deadlines during the transition.
How can an HRIS simplify compliance tracking?
An HRIS can simplify compliance tracking by storing all employee data in one place and automating routine compliance tasks like reporting and documentation. However, most HRIS platforms need additional tools to handle the full complexity of multi-state regulations.
Can HRIS systems automate multi-state compliance?
HRIS systems can automate some multi-state compliance tasks like data management and basic reporting, especially with AI features. However, full automation typically requires specialized compliance partners beyond what most HRIS platforms offer on their own.
Where can HRIS systems fall short with multi-state compliance?
HRIS systems fall short with multi-state compliance because they can’t automatically track changing state laws or handle complex registration requirements. They also lack specialized workflows for managing compliance across different legal environments.
