Strategies for Building an HR Department After Leaving a PEO

Building an HR department from scratch can feel overwhelming, especially after leaving a PEO. Complicating matters, every company has its own unique set of challenges—from payroll processes and hiring tools to compliance practices and tech. Needless to say, knowing how to create a strong HR foundation is key to moving forward with confidence.

Today, we’re discussing what matters most when designing an effective HR function. Remember, as you transition out of a PEO, you’re going to need a detailed gameplan, one that helps you make smart decisions about policies, technology, onboarding, and more, ensuring you meet every HR need, no matter your company’s size or lifecycle stage. And as always, Mosey is here to lead the way. So let’s get started.

Key Takeaways

Choose the right HR model: Decide whether to build an in-house team, use external partners, or go hybrid after leaving a PEO.
Set clear HR foundations: Define roles, processes, and tools to support payroll, compliance, and employee needs.
Align HR with growth: Build strategies that support business goals and scale with your team over time.

Understanding the Role of Human Resources in the Workplace

To state the obvious, HR is essential in how companies hire, support, and grow their teams. A solid HR setup helps create a workplace where people are productive, engaged, and treated fairly, keeping the business in line with the law along the way.

Core HR Functions

At its core, HR is all about managing people. That includes much more than just hiring and firing. Companies just building out this critical function can handle it in a few different ways:

In-house HR team – A dedicated HR team with employees who work directly for the business and manage all HR tasks
HRO (Human Resources Outsourcing) – A third-party provider that handles specific functions like payroll, benefits, or compliance
HR consultants – Independent experts brought in for specific projects or ongoing support
Hybrid model – A mix of internal staff and external partners, depending on the company’s size and needs

Of course, each option has trade-offs in cost, control, and flexibility. Today, however, we will be focusing primarily on an in-house model since it requires the most time and effort for a company.

Still, no matter the setup, most HR teams or partners help with:

Recruiting and hiring – Finding and bringing on the right people
Payroll and benefits – Making sure employees are paid correctly and have access to insurance and retirement plans
Training and development – Helping staff build skills and grow in their roles
Compliance – Following employment laws and keeping policies up to date
Employee relations – Handling feedback, resolving issues, and supporting a positive work environment

Why a Solid HR Plan Matters

In practice, these core functions ensure a strong HR that helps businesses hire better, keep people longer, and avoid costly mistakes. It improves workplace culture, boosts employee satisfaction, and supports long-term growth.

So, whether you build HR internally or partner with outside help, having the right support in place makes a real difference. And it all stems from a robust, rock-solid HR plan that takes both today and tomorrow into account.

Download our free PEO Transition Guide

Learn to bring processes in-house, which critical services to implement, and how to remain compliant.

Download guide

Establishing a Strong HR Department

A reliable and effective HR department is key for recruiting, supporting, and managing employees. To set the foundation, clear HR roles should be defined, the right team must be chosen, and everyday duties need to be well understood.

HR Structure and Roles

Every HR department should be built on a solid structure. Most often, it starts with an HR manager or director who oversees everything. Under this leader, there might be specialists for recruiting, training, benefits, and payroll.

A simple beginning structure might be as straightforward as:

HR Manager – Leads the department
Recruiter – Handles hiring
HR Generalist – Supports daily operations
Payroll Specialist – Manages salaries
Benefits Coordinator – Administers employee benefits

Having defined roles helps avoid confusion and lets team members become experts in their own areas. This structure works for both small and growing companies. Over time, more roles can be added as the company gets bigger.

Building an Effective HR Team

An effective HR team starts with hiring people who work well together and have the right skills. Moreover, a mix of experience is helpful. Some team members might have worked in HR for years, while others bring new ideas and energy.

Communication plays a critical role at every stage of HR building. Every team member should understand what is expected, who to go to for help, and how their job connects to company goals. In this regard, regular meetings and open feedback make the team stronger.

Training and development should be another ongoing initiative for an in-house HR team. Offering chances to learn about new laws, hiring tools, or better ways to support staff keeps the team up-to-date. When the HR team is supported, the whole company benefits.

Designing HR Strategies for Organizational Growth

Looking at the bigger picture, strong HR strategies give an organization direction and help guide both short-term decision-making and long-term success. Focusing on planning and connecting HR to broader business goals makes it easier to manage growth and adjust to change.

Creating an HR Strategy

First, HR leaders need to study the organization’s current situation. They often start with a SWOT analysis to look at strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. This helps them understand what the company already does well and where there are gaps.

Next, they set clear goals, such as improving hiring processes or building skills in current employees. Setting timelines and picking the right people to lead these efforts is important.

Key elements of a strong HR strategy:

Workforce planning: Forecasting future staff needs
Talent management: Attracting, developing, and keeping top talent
Employee learning and development: Providing regular training
Performance management: Setting goals and giving feedback

When the steps are clear and tracked, HR teams can quickly spot what’s working and what needs to change.

Aligning HR with Business Goals

Successful organizations ensure that HR actions support their main goals. This means leadership should clearly explain company priorities so HR can adjust hiring, training, and policies to match those needs.

For example, if the business wants to expand into new markets, HR might focus on hiring people with local experience or starting diversity programs to reach new customers. If technology is a priority, leadership might invest in IT training for staff.

Ways to align HR and business goals:

Hold regular meetings between HR and management.
Share updates on business plans.
Link performance reviews to business targets.
Update HR policies to match changing goals.

Once again, by keeping communication open, HR helps everyone move in the same direction, supporting both growth and stability.

Recruitment and Hiring Best Practices

Planning and carrying out strong recruitment and hiring steps helps a company find capable employees quickly. Using clear methods and tools guides managers and staff to successful results.

Recruiting Process Overview

The recruiting process begins with understanding the needs of each department. Department managers and HR work together to create job descriptions that are specific and up-to-date. These descriptions should list main duties, needed skills, and any special requirements.

After preparing the job description, the team decides where to post the job. Common options include the company website, job boards, and social media. Some roles also get shared with industry groups or local colleges.

Next, HR collects applications and reviews them. Simple checklists help spot candidates who meet the job criteria. At this stage, early phone screens or emails can be used to confirm interest and basic qualifications. Keeping each step organized ensures fair and quick selection.

Building an Effective Hiring Process

A strong hiring process uses clear steps from screening to final offer. The process often starts with a short list based on resumes and applications. Each candidate should go through the same steps for every role so the process is fair.

For interviews, it helps to use a set of standard questions. This makes comparing candidates easier and keeps the process balanced. Department managers and HR often work together on these interviews.

After interviews, notes on each candidate’s strengths and weaknesses are gathered. This feedback should be shared quickly. Deciding on a candidate should involve both the HR team and department managers. Once a decision is made, a formal offer is prepared and sent to the chosen applicant.

Applicant Tracking Systems

Applicant tracking systems (ATS) are online tools that help manage job postings and applications. An ATS makes it easy to post open positions on several sites at once. It also lets HR track which candidates have applied, their status, and notes from interviews.

Features like email templates and interview scheduling help save time. Some systems rank or sort applicants based on keywords or skills. This automation makes it easier to handle lots of applications, especially during busy hiring seasons.

ATS tools also provide reports and insights. They can tell HR how fast roles are filled and where strong candidates are coming from. This helps improve the recruiting and hiring process over time.

Download our free HR compliance guide

Learn how to measure HR success, develop compliance strategies, and grow your career.

Download guide

Onboarding and Employee Development

Successful HR teams pay close attention to how new employees are welcomed and supported as they settle in. Ongoing employee training, skills development, and professional growth keep the workforce engaged and ready for change, improving the employee experience as well.

Effective Onboarding Processes

Onboarding begins with a clear plan that outlines an employee’s first days and weeks. Managers provide them with essential tools, policies, and system access from the start. A well-organized orientation introduces them to the company’s mission, values, and key colleagues.

Checklist-based onboarding helps ensure no key tasks are missed, including crucial areas like:

Workstation setup
HR paperwork
Team introductions
Initial training sessions

Some companies even assign mentors to guide new hires during their first few months. Regular check-ins and feedback help quickly address any questions, making the transition smoother. With structured onboarding, employees feel welcomed, informed, and better prepared to contribute.

Training and Development Initiatives

After onboarding, employees greatly benefit from ongoing training programs. These can include both in-person and online learning, workshops, or job-specific courses. The main aim is to address skills gaps and support performance.

Common training methods:

Skill-specific e-learning modules
Cross-training with other teams
Leadership development workshops
On-the-job shadowing

Managers often use skills gap analysis to find areas where employees need improvement. By checking skill levels against job requirements, they can customize learning plans for individuals or teams. Consistent learning and development efforts boost overall productivity and morale.

Professional and Employee Growth

But supporting employee growth involves more than technical training. Professional development includes coaching, career path planning, and regular feedback sessions. These programs help workers set and achieve personal goals within the organization.

HR teams may even offer resources like tuition support, job rotation, and networking events. When employees see clear paths to advancement, they’re more likely to stay motivated, boosting employee engagement across the entire company. Regular conversations about strengths, interests, and ambitions make it easier to find new opportunities for career growth.

Ultimately, a focus on both personal and professional development leads to greater job satisfaction and long-term retention. Companies investing in their people benefit from a skilled, adaptable, and engaged workforce.

Performance Management Systems

A strong performance management system tracks employee progress and sets clear expectations. Managers and team members work together to set SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound). These goals help employees understand what needs to be done and how success is measured.

Regular feedback is important in this process. Instead of just meeting once a year, ongoing check-ins let employees know how they are doing. Employee performance records keep track of achievements, skills, and areas needing growth.

Compensation, Benefits, and Payroll Administration

Strong HR departments handle pay, benefits, and payroll with care and accuracy. These functions help attract top talent, keep employees happy, and avoid expensive legal issues for the company.

Designing Competitive Compensation Packages

Competitive compensation starts with researching similar jobs in the industry. Salary surveys, job market data, and internal pay structures give a clear starting point. HR teams usually create clear pay grades and salary bands so employees know what to expect.

A well-designed package includes more than base pay. It covers bonuses, incentives, and non-cash rewards such as employee recognition programs. Listing all components of a job offer in a proposal table can help managers streamline the approval process.

Frequent reviews keep the packages aligned with business goals and budget. Honest conversations about pay help build trust and reduce turnover.

Benefits Management

Benefits are a major reason candidates choose one job over another. Popular offerings include health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, and employee wellness programs. Companies often tailor packages to fit the size of the HR budget and the needs of their workforce.

HR managers must balance benefit quality with overall costs. They need to work with providers, compare plan options, and make sure offerings meet workplace laws. An annual review helps spot changes in employee needs or regulations.

Communicating benefit details is crucial. Simple guides, Q&A sessions, or benefits fairs help employees understand what is available so they can make smart choices.

Payroll Processes and Compliance

Payroll must be accurate and on time for every employee. This process involves tracking hours, deducting taxes, paying health premiums, and making retirement plan contributions. HR departments often use payroll software to reduce errors and save time.

Staying compliant with tax laws and labor rules is vital. Mistakes can lead to penalties or employee frustration, so HR keeps careful records. Regularly update processes to match new laws or business changes, often with the help of a partner like Mosey who can streamline payroll compliance, taking a massive burden off of an HR team.

Employee Handbooks, Compliance, and Employee Relations

Effective HR practices depend on clear policies, strong compliance, and positive employee relations. Each area helps protect the company, improve workplace culture, and keep everyone on the same page.

Employee Handbooks: Crafting HR Policies for an Organization

Well-written policies and procedures shape how a company runs every day. These documents cover key topics like attendance, time off, workplace safety, and use of technology, all housed within a centralized employee handbook that evolves along with the company itself.

To write strong HR policies—and, thus, a stout employee handbook—leaders must use clear language, define expectations, and ensure all employees can easily understand them. Involving managers and team members in the process helps catch possible problems early.

Key areas to include in HR policies:

Attendance: Tardiness, Absence Reporting
Conduct: Anti-harassment, Dress Code
Safety: Emergency Plans, Equipment Use
Benefits: Leave Policies, Health Plans

Regular reviews help keep policies in line with new laws or business changes. Of course, this is another area where Mosey shines, ensuring your employee handbook is always up-to-date. Further, since all policies are written by attorneys, you can also rest easy knowing your policies are legally sound.

Ensuring Multi-State Compliance

Speaking of areas where Mosey shines, HR teams also face special challenges when working across state lines. Each state may have its own rules for things like minimum wage, paid leave, overtime, meal breaks, and final paychecks.

Companies must track these rules and update policies as laws change. Using reliable sources for legal updates is essential. For example, a vacation rule in one state might be illegal in another.

HR should train managers in each state about local compliance guidelines since failing to follow rules can lead to fines, lawsuits, or employee complaints. Elsewhere, some still use traditional methods like state-by-state tracking charts and spreadsheets for managing multi-state compliance. However, forward-looking companies use tools like Mosey to automate those countless tedious but critical tasks involved in multi-state compliance, again easing the burden on their team while also freeing them to focus on growth.

Manage required policies across every state.

Automatically track policy changes and easily apply them to your handbook. Never worry about missing state-specific policies.

Talk with an expert

Managing Employee Conduct and Relations

Clear policies guide employee conduct, but positive relations come from more than just rules. HR needs to respond quickly to issues like conflicts, performance problems, or workplace gossip.

Open communication channels make it easier for employees to share concerns early. Many HR teams use regular check-ins, feedback sessions, and surveys to spot problems before they grow.

When problems do come up, fair investigations and consistent discipline are important. Handling issues with respect and privacy builds trust. Focusing on both policies and relationships helps keep teams working together smoothly.

Leveraging HR Technology and Software Solutions

Modern HR technology helps streamline daily tasks and reduce administrative burden for HR teams. By choosing the right systems and tools, companies can increase efficiency, improve data accuracy, and allow staff to focus more on strategic priorities.

Selecting HRIS and HRMS Solutions

Choosing a Human Resource Information System (HRIS) or Human Resource Management System (HRMS) is an important step for any organization. These platforms bring HR functions—such as payroll, benefits, and employee data management—into one place. When selecting an HRIS or HRMS, it is best to identify the company’s core needs first.

Make sure to check for user-friendly interfaces and strong data security. Look for features like automated reporting, integration with other tools (such as payroll and time tracking), and support options. Suffice to say, selecting the right system reduces manual administration and makes HR tasks more manageable.

Optimizing HR Processes Through Technology

Using HR software can automate many routine tasks and free up valuable time. Tools can schedule interviews, track applications, and manage onboarding without the need for manual paperwork. This reduces errors and helps HR teams respond faster to staff needs.

HR technology also supports outsourcing where needed, such as for payroll or benefits administration. Many platforms offer self-service options for employees, which lowers the administrative burden on HR staff. Digital records are easier to organize and search, making audits and compliance checks more straightforward.

By optimizing processes with technology, teams work more efficiently and have more time for important projects. Embracing new tools also makes it easier for companies to grow and adapt as their needs change.

Building an Ideal HR Function with Mosey

Leaving a PEO means having the freedom to build an HR function that actually fits your team, not just a one-size-fits-all solution. Whether you go in-house, partner with an HRO, or land somewhere in between, the right structure gives you more control, better alignment with your goals, and the flexibility to grow on your terms. Bottom line—while there’s no single right way to build HR, there definitely is a right way for your business. And that’s where Mosey enters the picture.

With Mosey, you can simplify your PEO transition by automating that mountain of state and local compliance tasks, including payroll tax registrations, employee handbook updates, the constant march of new and changing legislation, and more. The result? You actually get the time and bandwidth to focus on building a robust HR function, whatever that might look like for you.

Ready to streamline your HR operations and ensure compliance across all states? Book a demo today and see how Mosey can supercharge your HR transformation.

The Platform for State and Local Compliance